CareIndex
CareIndex
Post-Acute Care Intelligence
Research Area · Workforce & Staffing

14,710 nursing homes.
Every shift. Every RN hour.

Payroll-Based Journal staffing data across 11 quarters — RN coverage, contract dependency, zero-RN days, and weekend patterns. Built for staffing agencies and workforce analysts.

8,646
Facilities Not Meeting Staffing Benchmarks
CMS PBJ · Q3 2025
$470M
Federal Fines Levied (3yr)
CMS enforcement · active CMPs
10,041
Immediate Jeopardy Citations
Highest-severity · last 3 years
14.5M
Daily Staffing Records
Every shift · every facility
Source: CMS Payroll-Based Journal (PBJ) · CMS Enforcement Actions · CareIndex analysis
View Publications ↓
Staffing is the most heavily documented part of the industry

Nursing home staffing is the single most heavily documented operational metric in long-term care. CMS requires every certified facility to submit daily payroll records under Section 6106 of the Affordable Care Act, producing a dataset of 14.5 million daily records across 14,710 facilities. Other parts of facility operations — ownership, financials, quality — are reported at monthly, annual, or incident-based cadences. Staffing is reported every day.

The federal staffing benchmarks published in 2024 — 3.48 total hours per resident per day, 0.55 RN hours per resident per day, and 24/7 RN presence — remain the industry standard for evaluating staffing adequacy even after the federal mandate was repealed in December 2025. State-level enforcement now carries most of the accountability weight, and state minimums vary dramatically. Twelve states have no staffing floor at all. Five states fine facilities directly for understaffing. The remaining states rely on CMS survey findings as the primary enforcement mechanism.

Our work in this research area is to make the daily staffing data usable. We ingest the full PBJ dataset, normalize it against facility master records, split employee and contract hours across every nursing category, and compute composite scores from documented formulas. See the methodology page for how the data is built and the regulatory landscape for the state-by-state enforcement picture. Home health agency workforce intelligence — visit volume, VBP payment adjustments, and service area signals — is covered separately under the Skilled Nursing Home Health Hospice research area.

Core staffing metrics
Six metrics form the foundation of our staffing analysis. Each is derived directly from Payroll-Based Journal data with no imputation. Industry benchmarks referenced below are CMS-published 2024 standards.
Total HPRD
Hours per resident per day across all nursing categories — RN, LPN, and CNA combined. Industry benchmark is 3.48. This is the headline staffing number CMS uses in Care Compare.
CMS PBJ · daily · per facility
RN HPRD
Registered nurse hours per resident per day specifically. Industry benchmark is 0.55. This is the most critical metric for clinical quality and the hardest category for facilities to staff consistently.
CMS PBJ · daily · per facility
Zero-RN Days
Days on which a facility reports zero RN hours. The 24/7 RN presence standard flags any facility with even a single zero-RN day as out of compliance. Counted per facility per quarter.
CMS PBJ · derived
Contract Dependency
Contract (agency) hours as a share of total nursing hours, available for every facility and every nursing category. PBJ publishes paired employee and contract columns, making this measurable at daily granularity.
CMS PBJ · employee/contract split
Weekend Drop-off
The decline in staffing levels from weekday averages to weekend averages. Most facilities staff down on weekends to some degree; the question is how much, and how it varies by nursing category.
CMS PBJ · derived
Turnover
RN and total staff turnover rates, reported by CMS as annualized percentages. CMS suppresses this data for facilities below their disclosure threshold — see the methodology page for details.
CMS Provider Data Catalog
What the data currently shows
A snapshot of findings from the most recent refresh of our staffing dataset. For the full analysis and month-over-month changes, see the CareIndex Brief.
60%
Of nursing homes nationally fall below at least one of the three CMS 2024 staffing benchmarks.
SOURCE: CMS PBJ · CareIndex analysis
15%
Report one or more zero-RN days in the most recent quarter, meaning they fail the 24/7 RN presence standard.
SOURCE: CMS PBJ · CareIndex analysis
9.0%
Contract staffing share in New York — the highest in the country. Florida is the lowest at 1.2%.
SOURCE: CMS PBJ · state-level aggregation
Reports derived from this research area
Paid facility, state, and multi-state reports generated on demand from live data. Each report names the data layers and refresh dates it draws from. See the methodology page for how the scores are constructed.
Staffing Opportunity
$199
Facility-level staffing analysis
  • Staffing Opportunity Score with tier designation
  • Contract staffing profile from PBJ split
  • Daily HPRD pattern and zero-RN calendar
  • Observations derived from triggered thresholds
  • County-level opportunity ranking of 20 facilities
Learn More → View Sample Report →
Facility Profile
$299
Facility-level intelligence dossier
  • Contract dependency trend over time
  • Payer mix breakdown by Medicare, Medicaid, and private
  • Staffing stability score with sub-metric breakdown
  • Staffing gaps by nursing category
  • 20 nearest facility comparisons
Learn More → View Sample Report →
Single State
$299
Full state-level analysis
  • Complete state staffing analysis
  • County-level market breakdown
  • Top 25 facilities by staffing opportunity
  • Payer mix benchmarks by county
  • PDF and interactive HTML delivery
Learn More → View Sample Report →

Contact

14,710 facilities • 14.5M staffing records • 419K violations • 50 states

Your information is confidential. We never share data.